|\^/| Maple 7 (SUN SPARC SOLARIS) ._|\| |/|_. Copyright (c) 2001 by Waterloo Maple Inc. \ MAPLE / All rights reserved. Maple is a registered trademark of <____ ____> Waterloo Maple Inc. | Type ? for help. > _Envdiffopdomain; [DF, x] > y1,y2 := 1+a*x, x*x+b*x; 2 y1, y2 := 1 + a x, x + b x > LCLM(DF-diff(y1,x)/y1, DF-diff(y2,x)/y2); bytes used=1005232, alloc=851812, time=0.36 2 (1 + a x) DF a DF - 2 -------------- + 2 -------------- 2 2 a x + 2 x + b a x + 2 x + b > L1:=%; 2 (1 + a x) DF a L1 := DF - 2 -------------- + 2 -------------- 2 2 a x + 2 x + b a x + 2 x + b > symmetric_product(L1, DF^2); 4 DF > lprint(L1); DF^2-2*(1+a*x)/(a*x^2+2*x+b)*DF+2*a/(a*x^2+2*x+b) homogeneous: > L1:=DF^2-2*(c+a*x)/(a*x^2+c*2*x+b)*DF+2*a/(a*x^2+c*2*x+b); 2 (c + a x) DF a L1 := DF - 2 ---------------- + 2 ---------------- 2 2 a x + 2 c x + b a x + 2 c x + b > symmetric_product(L1, DF^2); bytes used=2005948, alloc=1507052, time=0.55 4 DF > L2:=symmetric_product(DF*DF, DF+coeff(L1,DF,1)/4); 2 2 2 2 (c + a x) DF 5 c + 6 a x c + 3 a x - 2 a b L2 := DF - ---------------- + 1/4 -------------------------------- 2 2 2 a x + 2 c x + b (a x + 2 c x + b) > L1:=symmetric_product(L1, DF-coeff(L1,DF,1)/4); 2 2 2 2 (c + a x) DF 3 a x + 6 a x c + 10 a b - 7 c L1 := DF - ---------------- + 1/4 --------------------------------- 2 2 2 a x + 2 c x + b (a x + 2 c x + b) > symmetric_product(L1,L2); 4 DF > L1-L2; 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 a x + 6 a x c + 10 a b - 7 c 5 c + 6 a x c + 3 a x - 2 a b 1/4 --------------------------------- - 1/4 -------------------------------- 2 2 2 2 (a x + 2 c x + b) (a x + 2 c x + b) > %/2; 2 2 2 2 2 2 3 a x + 6 a x c + 10 a b - 7 c 5 c + 6 a x c + 3 a x - 2 a b 1/8 --------------------------------- - 1/8 -------------------------------- 2 2 2 2 (a x + 2 c x + b) (a x + 2 c x + b) > %^2; / 2 2 2 2 2 2 \ | 3 a x + 6 a x c + 10 a b - 7 c 5 c + 6 a x c + 3 a x - 2 a b| |1/8 --------------------------------- - 1/8 --------------------------------|^ | 2 2 2 2 | \ (a x + 2 c x + b) (a x + 2 c x + b) / 2 > factor(%); 2 2 (a b - c ) 9/4 ------------------- 2 4 (a x + 2 c x + b) This is the function c(x) in the paper. You see that to make it into a rational function that depends linearly on (a:b:c) up to a some factor, you need to take c(x)^(-1/4), which explains how to find the result given in the paper.